American Idol is down to the top 4! They'll be singing songs from the movies! Jamie Foxx will be guiding the remaining 4 Idol wannabes, so let's get to it!
Randy - did nothing with the song, pitchy in spots, it was just okay.
Ellen - so good, she loved it.
Kara - one of the most difficult songs to sing; out of tune issues; off in parts
Simon - verging on karaoke
Big Mike is singing Will You Be There and I loved this performance.
Randy - wish he would have chosen an R & B song; just alright
Ellen - a bit predictable
Kara - didn't feel goosebumps; played it safe
Simon - doesn't make sense; could have chosen a better song; gave it 100%
First duet of the night: Crystal and Lee singing Falling Slowly and boy do they sound great together!
Casey James is singing Mrs. Robinson and I'm not liking it. He sounds like Tiny Tim!
Randy - wasn't jumping up and down over it; but curious about the subject matter. lol
Ellen - wished they would have given him a big boy guitar
Kara - good song choice.. LOL Oh, Mrs. Robinson.
Simon - didn't think the performance had the substance he needed tonight
Crystal Bowersox is singing I'm Alright from Caddyshack!!! I love this movie and she is doing a great job with it!
Randy - definitely an artist!
Ellen - took the song and made it better
Kara - agree with both Randy and Ellen
Simon - back in the game!!!
2nd duet of the night: Big Mike and Casey singing Have You Ever Really Loved A Woman? and I really like Big Mike's voice for this song, not Casey's so much. But they sounded great towards the end!
Wow, these guys were great. If I had to chose, I don't think Casey did as well as the others.
What do you think? Which American Idol wannabe is headed home?