Lee DeWyze sang The Letter very good in my opinion, but he still doesn't wow me.
Randy - knocked it out of the box.
Ellen - her favorite pen is back.
Kara - raised the bar for himself.
Simon - not a recording performance, but sounded good.
Paige Miles sang Against All Odds and she sounds scared to death! Weak performance.
Randy - honestly terrible.
Ellen - looked stunning.
Kara - stopped competing. Worst vocal of the season.
Simon - 5 of you singing the song; going to be in serious trouble.
Tim Urban sang Crazy Little Thing Called Love and he finally came out of his shell!
Randy - vocals were so boring; karaoke
Ellen - has fans that love him, but it felt like an audition for High School Musical.
Kara - didn't change it up at all.
Simon - completely pointless and silly.
Aaron Kelly sang I Don't Want To Miss A Thing and I love this kid! He's good!
Randy - not perfect, but he really likes him.
Ellen - so good; amazing.
Kara - best song choice of the night. Knows how to pick songs.
Simon - making himself old fashioned, but there's zero chance he's going home.
Crystal Bowersox sang Bobby McGee and if she isn't the next American Idol, she'll go places.
Randy - that's what it's called being a star!
Ellen - nothing wrong with that performance, but we're missing personality.
Kara - felt more from her. hahhaha Crystal just put Kara in her place. Love it!
Simon - wouldn't change anything. As good as Pink's version of the song!!!
Big Mike sang When A Man Loves A Woman and Big Mike is my favorite teddy bear!
Randy - not the perfect song choice, but he knows who he is.
Ellen - safe choice, but she loves him.
Kara - really good, but a bit boring.
Simon - tons of charisma and a very good voice.
Andrew Garcias sang I Heard It Through The Grapevine a bit boring.
Randy - not good.
Ellen - hope he has a lot of fans.
Kara - confused.
Simon - overrated that great moment. Has had enough time to work this out.
Katie Stevens sang Big Girls Don't Cry and she's doing a lot better! She still looks like Tatiana though. lol
Randy - little pitchy, but she listened to the judges.
Ellen - best performance so far.
Kara - this is the lane for you. Mad pitch issues.
Simon - no idea what the heck he said. hahahha
Casey James sang Power Of Love and although I love him, I think he thinks he's always safe.
Randy - wasn't a fan of the song.
Ellen - totally missed what she said.
Kara - she's just in too much love; lust. Whatever.
Simon - old fashioned; no effort, no originality.
Didi Benam sang You're No Good like she's not even competing. Don't like her.
Randy - pitchy
Ellen - not the right song choice.
Kara - too dramatic.
Simon - like a bad part of a musical.
Siobhan Magnus sang Superstition very good, but she's another who thinks she's all that.
Randy - loved it.
Ellen - more please.
Kara - loves the way she expresses herself.
Simon - some people will like it but a lot of people won't. Too much screaming.
American Idol will send someone home. Who will it be???