- Randy – was an okay song choice and just an okay performance.
- Paula – the song left her with a big appetite.
- Simon – it was a little bit copycat, but good enough to make it through.
- Randy – in the zone; nice!
- Paula – looks like a star!
- Simon – just a bad “shrieky” version, and a bad interpretation of Tina Turner.
- Randy – dude, that was really karaoke.
- Paula – performed for the audience, but not crazy about the performance.
- Simon – that was utterly atrocious; the first round was a massacre!
- Randy – that was hot!
- Paula – something about him and being seasoned.
- Simon – best performance so far.
- Randy – this is the David Cook we’ve grown to love; that was great!
- Paula – wants more David Cook. That’s a little creepy, Paula.
- Simon – welcome back David Cook!
Paula Made One Cry!
- Randy – did not love the performance.
- Paula – stood up, applauded, and said it was beautiful and made Syesha cry!
- Simon – agreed with Paula and Syesha cried harder! Simon also said that Randy got that all wrong, and Ryan thanked Randy for the buzz kill. LOL
Simon Says Pack Your Bags!
- Randy – not in the zone tonight.
- Paula – you blow me away. Is that good or bad Paula?
- Simon – says I’d pack your suitcase.
- Randy – another great performance!
- Paula – favorite performance so far.
- Simon – you didn’t beat the competition, you crushed the competition.
Is Simon right? Will Jason Castro be leaving us tonight? Vote now!