When Ryan started separating the Idol contestants into groups, it really wasn’t obvious at first which ones would be in the bottom 3. I knew David Cook wouldn’t be, but I thought Brooke and/or Kristy would be in the bottom 3.
As soon as Ryan switched Syesha and David it was very obvious who were in the bottom 3. Syesha should not have been there, it should have been Brooke, Kristy, and Carly, with Carly getting the boot.
The Wrong Idol Contestant Went Home
Syesha has a great voice so I just don’t understand why she is in the bottom every week, especially after this week’s performance. The judges gave her a better review than they gave Carly. Simon even said Syesha was very, very good. So, someone needs to explain to me why Syesha is always at the bottom.
Watch the teary video of Kristy’s elimination below and try to ignore Brooke and her little hissy fit.