Aaron Kelly is singing Long And Winding Road fantastic as usual, except he sounds nervous and unsure.
Randy - great voice, but the song was too sleepy.
Ellen - felt like a long and winding song.
Kara - have to be great, but has not reached that level yet.
Simon - it was old-fashioned and boring. Doing the same thing every week.
Katie Stevens is singing Let It Be and doing an awesome job!
Randy - best performance ever! Hot vocals!
Ellen - no way she'll be in the bottom 3.
Kara - blossoming, and a great attitude; confident!
Simon - tonight she got it right; Simon's taking credit.
Andrew Garcias is singing Can't Buy Me Love and he's good but not great.
Randy - solid performance; little corny.
Ellen - perfect song choice; loved it.
Kara - want to love it but doesn't see anything new.
Simon - band overpowered the whole arrangement. Got it all wrong.
Big Mike is singing Eleanor Rigby and it is fabulous!!!
Randy - the parts that worked, really worked!
Ellen - incredible.
Kara - fire; vocals were amazing.
Simon - didn't love it.
Crystal Bowersox is singing Come Together and of course she can sing anything!
Randy - another solid performance.
Ellen - needs a new way to tell her how good she is.
Kara - favorite performance.
Simon - that's a song I could hear on the radio.
Tim Urban is singing All My Loving same ole, same ole. Can he go home now?
Randy - better performance than the past couple of weeks.
Ellen - perfect song choice; 2nd best performance. What?
Kara - played guitar which is good.
Simon - thought he did really well. What are these judges on???
Casey James is singing Jealous Guy and I loved him once, but he's just been a goof lately.
Randy - missed what he said.
Ellen - beautiful... repetitive.
Kara - tasteful; showing depth.
Simon - the best performance of the night so far.
Siobhan Magnus is singing Across The Universe and she is done; she needs to go! Whine Alert!
Randy - loves everything she does, but it was a little sleepy.
Ellen - she's special. Yes she is...
Kara - hit the notes; showed control; but too restrained and polite.
Simon - came back much stronger this week. Then fell apart Simon, were you not paying attention?
Lee DeWyze is singing Hey Jude and I love this kid!
Randy - loved the bagpipes! You got this!
Ellen - smiling and it was a great job.
Kara - few off moments, but still a fan.
Simon - would not have done the bagpipes. Turned up on the wrong show. LOL
Another week, another whiner. Who should go home? S-Bon needs to go! She is creeping me out and she's NO American Idol!!!