American Idol needs ratings like every show, but we’re also seeking the next “American Idol.” So what possessed the Idol judges to choose Tatiana del Toro, the giggling mermaid, over the extremely gorgeous and talented Leneshe Young? Yippee, we get to see more of Norman Gentle, or whatever character he’s using, too! Ewwww! Many people are upset that Leneshe Young got the boot. I really thought she had a shot of becoming the next American Idol, or at least in the top 12. Did the American Idol judges make the right decision?