American Idol revamped their format to revive a very successful, yet stale show. Problem is American Idol writers/producers really screwed up. They added a 4th judge who brings nothing to the show. She tries to emulate Simon Cowell but doesn’t have the charm to pull it off. American Idol’s top 12 are chosen in a completely ridiculous way. Who put these groups together? American Idol was a bore fest last night. Some of these Idol wannabes should have been in last week’s group. That way maybe Matt Giraud who can actually sing would have made the top 12 where he belonged. Lil Rounds will make it. The judges had their comments ready beforehand. They didn’t have to listen to her sing. I love American Idol but if this train wreck continues, how long can it last?